New with Tags is the highest of the five condition grades on WishThrift. At this grade pet supplies are listed across the full range for the category, $13 to $243 (about £10 to £180), because nothing has been discounted for wear. Unused with the tag, and never introduced to an animal. Scent is the reason this grade carries a premium that other categories would not give it.
Where the line falls
Pet equipment is judged on hygiene before wear: an item is bought on whether it can be cleaned properly, and chew damage decides the rest.
For comparison, one step down is Like New Pet Supplies.
What pet supplies are worth here
| Grade | Share of top price | Typical range |
|---|---|---|
| New with Tags | about 100% | $13 to $243 |
| Like New | about 85% | $11 to $206 |
Guide ranges, not quotes, at £1 ≈ $1.35 (August 2026). All five grades.
What holds the value at this grade
- Aquarium — Complete setups with filter, heater, light and stand
- Bird Cage — Correct bar spacing for the species
- Cat Tree — Solid, stable bases that do not rock
- Dog Bed — Removable, washable covers
- Dog Crate — Correct sizing for common breeds
- Dog Kennel — Sound, treated timber with no rot
- Hamster Cage — Larger cages meeting welfare guidance
- Pet Carrier — Airline-compliant dimensions where relevant
- Pet Stroller — Smooth-running wheels with no wobble
- Aquarium — Tanks with no chips, cracks or failing seals
Listing at the New with Tags grade
Photograph the tag and say clearly that no animal has used it. Buyers with territorial or nervous pets search specifically for that.
Shots that carry the most weight in pet supplies:
- Aquarium — The aquarium set up and running, whole, including the cabinet
- Bird Cage — The cage whole, from the front
- Cat Tree — The whole tree upright, whole, against a plain wall
- Dog Bed — The bed whole, from above, plumped
On a typical $128 listing, a marketplace charging 20% takes $26, one charging 13.6% takes $17 and one charging 10% takes $13. WishThrift charges neither side, so you keep the whole $128. Listing is free.
Browse pet supplies
See every listing at the New with Tags grade, or the whole Pet Supplies category at every grade. The grade is the seller’s own; WishThrift does not inspect or verify items.
Other grades in pet supplies: Like New, Good, Fair, For Parts.
Common questions
Has an animal ever used it?
Tags on, no hair worked into the seams, and fabric with no smell of another animal on it at all.
What is the difference between New with Tags and Like New pet supplies?
Anything falling short of New with Tags is graded Like New Pet Supplies.