Used Tiffany and Co jewellery and watches typically sell for $18 to $2,745 (about £14 to £2,040) depending on the piece and its condition. Jewellery divides sharply into precious metal and everything else, and the whole listing follows from which one you have. A hallmark or a metal stamp is what a buyer looks for first, and describing plated or crystal-set pieces as silver or gold is the fastest route to a dispute.
What Tiffany and Co jewellery and watches sell for used
| Item | Typical used range | Value guide |
|---|---|---|
| Engagement Ring | $229 to $2,745 | Tiffany and Co Engagement Ring |
| Gold Watch | $137 to $1,372 | Tiffany and Co Gold Watch |
| Vintage Watch | $114 to $1,144 | Tiffany and Co Vintage Watch |
| Gold Ring | $91 to $915 | Tiffany and Co Gold Ring |
| Gold Necklace | $91 to $915 | Tiffany and Co Gold Necklace |
| Wedding Band | $91 to $801 | Tiffany and Co Wedding Band |
| Gold Earrings | $69 to $686 | Tiffany and Co Gold Earrings |
| Pearl Necklace | $46 to $343 | Tiffany and Co Pearl Necklace |
| Charm Bracelet | $34 to $274 | Tiffany and Co Charm Bracelet |
| Bracelet | $23 to $206 | Tiffany and Co Bracelet |
| Silver Necklace | $27 to $183 | Tiffany and Co Silver Necklace |
| Earrings | $18 to $183 | Tiffany and Co Earrings |
| Silver Ring | $23 to $137 | Tiffany and Co Silver Ring |
| Vintage Brooch | $18 to $114 | Tiffany and Co Vintage Brooch |
Prices are shown in US dollars, converted from pounds at £1 ≈ $1.35 (August 2026), and are approximate guide ranges rather than quotes. WishThrift shows listings in the local currency of each market.
Sizing, metal and hallmarks on Tiffany and Co jewellery and watches
Tiffany works largely in sterling silver alongside gold and platinum, and silver tarnishes with air rather than wearing out, so a dull piece is usually cleanable. Pieces carry maker and metal marks on the reverse or the shank.
- Sterling silver pieces lead what circulates here, measured on design and condition
- Gold and platinum pieces sit well above them and are priced on metal weight as well
- Because silver tarnish is reversible, a darkened piece is not the same as a damaged one
What to check before you buy
Photograph the marks on the reverse or inside the shank in good light, and note that tarnish is surface only. Confusing tarnish with damage understates a perfectly good piece.
For the checks that apply to any used jewellery and watches regardless of the maker, see the guide to buying used jewellery and watches.
What you keep when you sell
On a typical $1,382 Tiffany and Co piece, a marketplace charging 20% takes $276, one charging 13.6% takes $188 and one charging 10% takes $138. WishThrift charges neither side, so you keep the whole $1,382.
Listing your Tiffany and Co jewellery and watches
- Photograph the stamp, the clasp and the whole piece on a plain neutral background under one strong light. Jewellery photographed on a patterned surface disappears
- Consider selling charms and small pieces individually. Collectors hunt specific items, and a loaded bracelet often realises less than the sum of what is on it
Condition grades on WishThrift
Browse by grade: New with Tags, Like New, Good, Fair, For Parts. Grades are declared by the seller — WishThrift does not inspect or grade items, so the photographs and the description are what the grade rests on.
Other brands in jewellery and watches
Versace, Cartier, Chanel, Dior, Gucci, Hermès, Louis Vuitton, Pandora
Questions
Is tarnished silver damaged?
No. Tarnish is a surface reaction with air that polishes off, unlike scratching or pitting which are permanent. A darkened silver piece is usually worth the same as a bright one once cleaned, so describe it accurately rather than apologetically.
What marks should a silver piece carry?
A fineness mark for the metal and usually a maker’s mark, stamped on the reverse, the clasp or inside a ring shank. Photograph them close up, because they are the factual identification a buyer works from.
How much is used Tiffany and Co jewellery and watches worth?
Roughly $18 to $2,745 depending on the item and its condition. The table above breaks it down piece by piece, and each row links to a full value guide for that item.
How this guide is compiled
The ranges above are indicative asking prices in US dollars for comparable second-hand jewellery and watches, adjusted for where Tiffany and Co sits in its market — a guide, not a valuation of any individual item. WishThrift does not authenticate, inspect or grade: condition is declared by the seller. Last reviewed August 2026.
Tiffany and Co resale value guides · Browse jewellery and watches · More used Tiffany and Co